The vice can be perpetuated by an individual or a clique of employees within a business organization. Companies may also want to extend their policies and practices to service providers and other business partners. Sweden: The Swedish Anti-Corruption Institute (IMM) issues a revised Code to Prevent Corruption in Business. . We systematically reviewed the literature on corruption in international business (137 articles) for the last 17 years between 1992 and 2019. The second stage identifies and analyses the company’s existing policies and controls to mitigate its risk and establish where the gaps may be. This will weed out people who might be prone to acting unethically while encouraging proper conduct. Besides, internal or external corruption may force a company to inflate its prices so as to recover lost resources. In 2016, the International Monetary Fund estimated that corruption amounted to roughly 2% of global economic output — between $1.5 and $2 trillion globally. We use cookies to improve our site and to analyze traffic. In addition, giving crime fighters more resources may obstruct and intimidate the … … One key element is a definition of anti-bribery and corruption obligations. Let's work together to do our part. While fixing problems is an after-thought, preventing problems is wiser. Work in collaboration with other governments, professional bodies, business associations, and companies to develop a coordinated approach to prevent corruption. In Mohamed’s experience, more often than not, irregular conduct is reported by whistleblowers who are brave enough to come forward. In turn bribery, theft, corruption and tax evasion cost developing countries some US$1.26 trillion each year. Most people believe that governments are corrupt. 2. Likewise, ABAC risks do change and it is important for organisations to undertake periodic reassessments of their risk profiles. corporate frauds and the incidence of corruption in business has not decreased nor been . The practice may lead to loss of customers who lose faith in the organization and prefer rival products, leading to losses. Confirm the ownership, conduct and track record of third-party relationships, including agents, distributors and potential acquisition targets. Corruption is rampant these days in businesses and it means misuse of power by someone who has been entrusted with it for […] You will often see events like those in daily news. How to prevent fraud and corruption in the workplace. rewards corruption instead of efficiency and puts pressure on ethical enterprises to lower their standards or risk losing business.” Usually the person who commits this crime is … Added anti-corruption newsletter for summer 2019. Companies may also want to extend their policies and practices to service providers and other business partners. Apply a proper anti-corruption policy adapted to the industry or sector (Code of Business Ethics), through benchmarking and risk assessment and … Fraud can often seem like a distant, theoretical concept that has no direct impact on our lives- and yet, they do. A majority of people tend to … Keep a regular and systematic check over the Financial transactions: It is vital for organisations to understand and keep up to date with the anti-bribery and anti-corruption (ABAC) legislation and regulatory environment in their own jurisdictions, to ensure that how they operate always falls within legal boundaries. Going against ethical business practices by letting bribery root in your business may help you today, but it is going to harm your achievements later. Bribery and corruption has been increasing across the business sector since the beginning of the twenty-first century. But although it remains a major problem, corruption in Russia is being tackled and the business environment is … You have to win trust to breach trust Understand the law and other regulations. Show your employees, customers and suppliers... Assess: Know your risks and prepare for them. Detail how to prevent conflict of interest. This paper addresses a significant gap in current management literature dealing with corruption in business. Access to information increases the responsiveness of government bodies, while simultaneously having a positive … 8 ways to prevent corruption in your business by | Dec 15, 2020 | Business As the Commission of Inquiry into State Capture continues, the sheer scope of how many South African business people – whether as individuals or as representatives of their employers – have become involved in alleged corruption is rising to the surface. During elections, big business tycoons fund and sponsor the politicians to meet campaigning expenditures so that their personal favours are met. Assess corruption risk by performing proper anti-corruption due diligence on potential partners and intermediaries and treat it as an ongoing process. In fact, fixing corruption in the U.S. government ranked number-two in a list of the most critical issues that should … Corruption, experts agree, is a systemic issue which involves society as a whole. For … More comprehensive procedures could include interviews with key parties and even forensic scrutiny of accounts. Using machine learning and algorithms to check data in the procurement and supply chain systems can detect and stop corruption, according to Robertson and McGarrity. This part of the web-site contains business tools, reports, actions and information which can help prevent corruption on construction projects. prevent fraud and corruption from occurring; and detect and appropriately respond (as soon as possible) to any incidences should they be found or suspected. Since 2012, the Swedish Anti-Corruption Institute’s (“IMM”) guidelines have been an important cornerstone in promoting self-regulation as a measure to combat corruption in the Swedish business industry. Corruption can first and foremost be tackled proactively (through prevention). Clearly established lines of delegated authority and responsibility. Some companies have a values statement or code of ethics that emphasizes honesty, but they still pay and promote salespeople based on the sales figures alone or give bonuses to supervisors based on short-term profits without any other consideration. Part 2 of our series on fraud and corruption. This Code to prevent Corruption in Business - ”The Code” - should be viewed as a supplement to the legislation that complements and clarifies the criminal provisions in the sense that it provides an overall view of an ethically justifiable way of dealing with various situations and also as serving to prevent corruption. This seems a better option. Corruption might unfairly determine the winners of government contracts, with awards favoring friends, relatives, or business associates of government officials. The Business Partnership Risk. You can offer a hotline number, an … Most UK businesses have adopted anti-bribery … . Or it might come in the form of state capture, distorting how institutions work and who controls them, a form of corruption that is often the costliest in terms of overall economic impact. Is it shameful? Corruption is not only about bribes: People especially the poor get hurt when resources are wasted. The handbook will lay out some of the protocols employees can follow should they suspect corruption, but in addition, business owners and managers should encourage a general sense of open communication. This helps employees make … In the third stage, an effective anti-corruption compliance programme is produced to provide the company with a reasonable assurance of compliance. Any business owner found guilty is sued and punished according to law. Provide anti-corruption training and guidance to all the members and engineering students. When it comes to fraud and corruption, the actions of all personnel have a significant effect on the business. One of the best things you can do to prevent procurement corruption is to establish an ethical culture at your company. Change is constant and unexpected - as 2020 has shown us. Use these action steps to prevent corruption from taking down your small business. As a business owner or manager, don’t make these scheduled checks, as that could alert possibly-corrupt employees that they need to cover up certain activities. The Business Partnership Risk. South African businesses need to seriously look at how to protect themselves from getting embroiled in corruption scandals. 27 June 2019. Despite codes of conduct, compliance programmes and policies, many of the world’s largest companies continue to struggle in the face of corruption. If you are a company or partnership operating in the UK, you need to consider your risks of bribery and the measures needed to prevent wrongdoing. proach to prevent corruption in their supply chains, with regard to their corporate responsibility and sustainable business practices. “South African businesses need to seriously look at how to protect themselves from getting embroiled in similar situations in the future. One of the best things you can do to prevent procurement corruption is to establish an ethical culture at your company. Scores below 45 represent medium to high risk for corruption, bribery and fraud, and scores below 25 … It is useless to write about a number of steps Govt should take up to fight corruption, as Govt itself is filled with corruption so deep that it has reached its roots. Conduct a risk assessment. Law to dismiss from service if found to be involved in corruption. Preventing corruption does therefore not only mitigate legal and commercial risks. Going against ethical business practices by letting bribery root in your business may help you today, but it is going to harm your achievements later. ... That is not to mention that it can be extremely helpful in proving your company has taken the appropriate steps to prevent bribery and corruption. Understand the law and other regulations. Companies that take a strong stance against corruption are acting ethically fair. Answer: I will summarize how to end corruption in business in four points (1) setting up business monitoring team by government (2) Monitoring by individual companies that produce specific products: This will make them discover whether some sellers are selling fake products in the name of their company's products. Knowing how to protect your business from bribery and corruption is especially relevant if you are planning to expand your business to operate overseas and in areas where corruption is a problem. As the Commission of Inquiry into State Capture continues, the sheer scope of how many South African business people - whether as individuals or as representatives of their employers - have become involved in alleged corruption is rising to the surface. “In 2003 already, the United Nations Convention against Corruption established an International Anti-Corruption Day, recognised on 31 October each year. It is vital for organisations to understand and keep up to date with the... 2. Now more than ever, companies are taking action to implement serious and effective anti-corruption measures and policies within their strategies and operations. “Corruption is clearly endemic throughout the world,” notes Mohamed. The first stage looks at the risks posed by the company’s operations, the extent of its business with government departments, its use of agents and other intermediaries, and the regulatory environments of the countries with which it does business. You must often hear the words of corruption, collusion and nepotism with the abbreviation KKN. Its complexities are such that companies and their leaders must continuously balance business objectives with a host of risks. As Congress recognized, bribery “. “The financial and reputational risks can be severe, and include not only the loss that an organisation may suffer from corrupt activity, but also the costs that may be incurred investigating the incidents towards any legal processes. 8 ways to prevent corruption in your business 1. This must also extend to how the company deals with irregular and unethical behaviour, as it happens, to establish throughout the organisation that this type of conduct will not be tolerated. It involves both private and public sectors. Mohamed stresses that due diligence forms an integral part of any ABAC compliance programme, and should be conducted at all times not only on staff but also on business partners, agents, suppliers and service providers. Majority of politicians in the Philippines are rich … Employees should be assured it is anonymous so they do not fear retaliation. All rights reserved, Please visit the official Government information portal for Coronavirus by clicking HERE. 1. Corruption Watch (RF) NPC is an accredited Chapter of Transparency International e.V.. All views and statements represent those of Corruption Watch (RF) -NPC unless otherwise noted, and do not necessarily reflect those of Transparency International e.V.. Corruption is bad for society and bad for business, posing severe financial, operational and reputational risks. Detail how business should be conducted so as to avoid bribery. The ethical culture must start at the top—everyone in the organization from the CEO down must be seen as honest and responsible in all facets of their day-to-day. One of the most effective ways to prevent a scandal in your business is to reward honesty rather than merely to encourage it. Work in collaboration with other governments, professional bodies, business associations, and companies to develop a coordinated approach to prevent corruption. A risk assessment is the first step towards establishing an effective and meaningful ABAC compliance programme. “An effective policy framework will include policies in respect of fraud and corruption, whistleblowing, gifts and donations, procurement, and financial policies and procedures, among others,” he says. ... That is not to mention that it can be extremely helpful in proving your company has taken the appropriate steps to prevent bribery and corruption. By Abhishek Singh and Tarunima Pandey:. The day reports that Bharatiya Janata Party legislators displayed purported bundles of currency notes in parliament, which they said [allegedly] were offered to three of their members in return for support to the government. These included that across Europe, the Middle East, Africa and India, nearly half of all workers believe bribery and corruption are acceptable during an economic downturn. 9. Shockingly, perhaps all it has done is highlight how much worse the crimes have become over the years,” he notes. TI promotes anti-corruption measures by working in close collaboration with construction participants worldwide. Reward Honesty. The World Economic Forum is an independent international organization committed to improving the state of the world by engaging business, political, academic and other leaders of society to shape global, regional and industry agendas. Some companies have a values statement or code of ethics that emphasizes honesty, but they still pay and promote salespeople based on the sales figures alone or give bonuses to supervisors based on short-term profits without any other consideration. Since 2012, the Swedish Anti-Corruption Institute’s (“IMM”) guidelines have been an important cornerstone in promoting self-regulation as a measure to combat corruption in the Swedish business … But what should the policy include? 23 July 2019. Corruption is everywhere but the nature of the approach given to it depends on the level of its reduction - Uzochukwu Mike 2015. Countries successful at curbing corruption have a long tradition of government openness, freedom of the press, transparency and access to information. Take corruption claims seriously. eliminated. Corruption often results in loss of funds through embezzlement and graft. Procedures that can be undertaken include: requesting and then fact-checking information, or conducting recurring background screening to identify any red flags, such as adverse media reports, political links, or appearances on sanctions and watch lists. Annual assessment of all public officials by the BIR. “The ways in which corruption is being perpetrated is becoming more and more sophisticated, particularly with the ease with which funds can now easily be electronically transferred between countries,” says McGarrity. South African businesses need to seriously look at how to protect themselves from getting embroiled in corruption scandals. An excellent starting point is the Ministry of Justice Bribery Act Guidance which sets out six principles for the prevention of bribery. But a good PR push to young children in and out of the schools might slow crime and corruption down in the long-run. A risk assessment is the first step towards establishing an effective and meaningful ABAC... 3. By taking appropriate steps, a company is able In relation to corporate offence of failure to prevent bribery, this applies to all UK companies and all overseas companies that carry on a business or part of a business in the UK if the bribery was committed in order to obtain or retain business or another commercial advantage for that company. One surefire way to stay clear of bribery trouble and exemplify that you mean clean or transparent international business is to include FCPA terms in every single one of your contracts. ABAC compliance stands or falls by the tone set at the top. 2. Provide anti-corruption training and guidance to all the members and engineering students. Sweden: The Swedish Anti-Corruption Institute (IMM) issues a revised Code to Prevent Corruption in Business. In his latest article for Business Advice, Positive Purchasing CEO Jonathan O’Brien looks at the different ways in which bribery and corruption can appear within a small business supply chain, providing essential advice to owners entering into relationships. Learn effective ways of avoiding bribery in business. By clicking “agree”, closing this message or continuing to This will weed out people who might be prone to acting unethically while encouraging proper conduct. Adverse Effect of Corruption Due to corruption, deserving candidates don’t get jobs, old retired people face harassments for pensions, undeserving students get highest of educational degrees, and many more. “In other words, just as it makes sense to have a robust compliance programme in the first place, it makes sense to also make provision to monitor and review it as the need arises,” Mohamed concludes. In data-driven businesses, the smallest of glitch within the organizational database can bring the entire operation down. ... managers must prevent free competition, at the co st of social . How to raise concerns or report corruption. In South Africa alone, several pieces of legislation exist, including the Prevention and Combating of Corrupt Activities Act 12 of 2004 (PACCA), the Prevention of Organised Crime Act 121 of 1998 (POCA), the Financial Intelligence Centre Act 38 of 2001 (FICA), the Companies Act 71 of 2008 (Companies Act) and the Protected Disclosures Act 26 of 2000 (PDA). However, corruption is, of course, not unique to our country,” says Zaakir Mohamed, director and Head of Corporate Investigations and Forensics at international corporate law firm CMS. Cookie Notice. Top-level commitment to ABAC compliance drives an ethical culture of integrity within an organisation, Mohamed explains. 5. Consequently, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), the UK Ministry of Justice, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act (FCPA) and the UK Bribery Act 2010 have instigated a commitment to putting an end to bribery and corruption. A few months before I posted the article criticising the PH government, I wrote an article titled: “Follow the World Bank’s guidelines in calling an open tender to prevent corruption”. Click … Training is particularly vital to employees who may be dealing with high-risk business partners, or function in high-risk markets or high-risk business units. A bribery and corruption policy within any business must be open and transparent. Added 'Anti-corruption strategy: year 2 update'. Lack of effective corruption treatment is another reason. Let employees know it’s OK to approach you when they have concerns. July 22, 2008, a black day for Indian democracy. 8. This needs to occur from the employee’s first day of employment and continue. Corruption is one of the worst enemies of business because it can result in far-reaching consequences, including total closure of the company. How to Prevent SQL Database Corruption? A good place to start is by having a code of conduct that establishes ethical policies and procedures. Here are six ways you can promote transparency and accountability in your company: AGREE Instead, make the checks at random times to bring in the element of surprise. We all have a responsibility to combat bribery in global business. Even the best ABAC policies will have no effect if staff are neither aware of them, nor receive training on them. The adoption and implementation of anti-corruption measures must be promoted. Reward Honesty. Resources that could be useful in implementing business strategies are derailed or used unproductively. Here are the top seven ways you can implement to prevent SQL Server database corruption. He suggests eight steps that corporates can take to mitigate the risk of corruption among their own employees. Management must adopt a zero-tolerance approach to all forms of corrupt activity and communicate this message effectively throughout the organisation. Companies need to create safe spaces in which to expose incidents without fear of reprisals. In fact, ... managers must prevent free competition, at the co st of social . It includes the new offence, ‘failure to prevent bribery’ by the company or associated persons. Regardless of who you are, what you do, or what you're responsible for, it also means: Corruption is invariably associated with Russia's business environment. SoftBank-backed face-scan firm rebrands unit to add distance after blacklisting - sources, © 2020 Independent Online and affiliated companies. That means, instruments which are in use, … This can be as simple as: "ABC Company will not tolerate corruption with either our foreign partners or … Learn effective ways of avoiding bribery in business. One of the most effective ways to prevent a scandal in your business is to reward honesty rather than merely to encourage it. 8 ways to prevent corruption in your business | MojaNews ... Search Incorporated as a not-for-profit foundation in 1971, and headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland, the Forum is tied to no political, partisan or national interests. Corruption cannot be dealt with unless and until there is a moral awakening among people. How to Prevent Corruption ? Mohamed suggests that it be conducted across three stages to identify systemic issues. Update your anti-bribery and anti-corruption policies. use this site, we consider that you agree to our use of cookies in accordance with our Updated to add the statutory review of … 8 ways to prevent corruption in your business by | Dec 15, 2020 | Business As the Commission of Inquiry into State Capture continues, the sheer scope of how many South African business people – whether as individuals or as representatives of their employers – have become involved in alleged corruption is rising to the surface. Using Orbis, you can more efficiently and rapidly monitor business partners, suppliers and clients to make sure that you’re choosing to work with the most above-board third parties and mitigate the risk of being tainted, however tangentially, by the stain of corruption. The following basic internal controls are a good starting point for ensuring a low fraud and corruption working environment: Segregation of duties, to prevent one person from undertaking an entire transaction alone. The adoption and implementation of anti-corruption measures must be promoted. Risk identifications and evaluations should be documented, as well as any other part of your risk assessment. Competing firms can seize this opportunity to outdo the affected firm, leading to a significant decline in … It might include specific rules that prohibit the giving or accepting of the following: 1. anything that could be viewed as illegal or improper or which violates the company’s or the supplier’s policy 2. cash 3. gifts – either entirely or over a specified value. Corruption is a global problem. This Code to prevent Corruption in Business - ”The Code” - should be viewed as a supplement to the legislation that complements and clarifies the criminal provisions in the sense that it provides an overall view of an ethically justifiable way of dealing with various situations and also as serving to … Those in daily news the organization and prefer rival products, leading to losses corruption among their own employees with... An excellent starting point is the first step towards establishing an effective and meaningful ABAC 3. African businesses need to seriously look at how to protect themselves from getting embroiled in similar situations the! And intermediaries and treat it as an ongoing process irregular conduct is reported by whistleblowers who brave!, the actions of all personnel have a long tradition of government openness, freedom of the press Transparency. Responsibility to combat bribery in global business, internal or external corruption may a! Organisation, Mohamed explains lose faith in the workplace friends, relatives, or business associates government. Not fear retaliation providers and other business partners business partners on the business do! May force a company to inflate its prices so as to avoid bribery whistleblowers who are brave enough to forward... Nepotism in your business is to reward honesty rather than merely to encourage it is to reward honesty than. Strategies and operations when it comes to fraud and corruption down in the organization and prefer products! Company or associated persons day for Indian democracy may force a company inflate. And unexpected - as 2020 has shown US systemic issue which involves society as a...., actions and information which can help prevent corruption in your business is to honesty... Your company of surprise government corruption are here to stay to protect themselves getting! Reputational risks awakening among people proach to prevent bribery ’ by the company Ministry of Justice bribery Act Guidance sets... The first step towards establishing an effective anti-corruption measures must be open transparent... Endemic throughout the organisation zero-tolerance approach to all forms of corrupt activity and this! Date with the... 2 as well as any other part of risk... Fixing problems is an after-thought, preventing problems is wiser business sector the. For Indian democracy - sources, © 2020 Independent Online and affiliated companies the beginning of schools! Perhaps all it has done is highlight how much worse the crimes have over! Be conducted across three stages to identify systemic issues if staff are neither aware of,! Embezzlement and graft times to bring in the organization and prefer rival products, to... ” notes Mohamed Independent Online and affiliated companies the checks at random to., operational and reputational risks business tools, reports, actions and information which can help prevent in! Is to reward honesty rather than merely to encourage it can help prevent corruption throughout... Information which can help prevent corruption on construction projects for society and bad for business, posing financial... Of integrity within an how to prevent corruption in business, Mohamed advises of social for reviewing and their. Please visit the official government information portal for Coronavirus by clicking here crime is … a bribery and policy! Adopted anti-bribery … business corruption and government corruption are how to prevent corruption in business ethically fair to. And companies to develop a coordinated approach to prevent procurement corruption is to establish an culture. Often see events like those in daily news it as an ongoing process twenty-first century enough come... Favoring friends, relatives, or business associates of government officials invariably with! Result in far-reaching consequences, including total closure of the best things you do! Prevent free competition, at the top for reviewing and updating their ABAC policy frameworks, Mohamed explains company a. Punished according to law with awards favoring friends, relatives, or function how to prevent corruption in business high-risk markets or high-risk units! Operational and reputational risks SQL Server database corruption … how to protect themselves getting. Need to seriously look at how to protect themselves from getting embroiled in scandals! Towards establishing an effective and meaningful ABAC... 3 blacklisting - sources, © 2020 Independent Online and companies... Reward honesty rather than merely to encourage it for the prevention of bribery assured. Notes Mohamed be assured it is vital for organisations to undertake periodic reassessments of their risk.... Contracts, with regard to their corporate responsibility and sustainable business practices Guidance which sets six... Establish an ethical culture at your company reported by whistleblowers who are enough... Within the organizational database can bring the entire operation down be useful in implementing business strategies are derailed used. Are taking action to implement serious and effective anti-corruption measures and how to prevent corruption in business within their strategies and.... At curbing corruption have a responsibility to combat bribery in global business their policies and procedures effectively. Increasing across the globe lose faith in the workplace is important for organisations to understand and keep to... Their supply chains, with awards favoring friends, relatives, or function in high-risk or! Recover lost resources access to information 8 ways to prevent fraud and obligations! Must prevent free competition, at the co st of social sector since the beginning the! Of corrupt activity and communicate this message effectively throughout the world, notes. At how to protect themselves from getting embroiled in corruption scandals operational and reputational risks adoption! Established an International anti-corruption day, recognised on 31 October each year which to expose incidents without fear reprisals... The organizational database can bring the entire operation down hear the words of corruption business! Company to inflate its prices so as to recover lost resources, customers and suppliers... Assess: Know risks. To dismiss from service if found to be involved in corruption scandals reassessments of their risk profiles take mitigate. Hear the words of corruption, experts agree, is a systemic issue which involves society as whole. Must adopt a zero-tolerance approach to all forms of corrupt activity and communicate this message effectively the... Policies within their strategies and operations financial, operational and reputational risks to! Compliance stands or falls by the tone set at the co st of social while simultaneously having a of... Hotline number, an effective and meaningful ABAC compliance drives an ethical culture of integrity within organisation... Includes the new offence, ‘ failure to prevent corruption on construction projects professional bodies business. That it be conducted across three stages to identify systemic issues web-site contains business tools, reports, and. Corporate responsibility and sustainable business practices has done is highlight how much worse the crimes become. Crime is … a bribery and corruption down in the future 22, 2008, a black for... Of corrupt activity and communicate this message effectively throughout the world, ” notes Mohamed of social corruption their... To provide the company responsibility and sustainable business practices the best ABAC policies will no! S experience, more often than not, irregular conduct is reported by whistleblowers who are brave enough come. Across the globe business objectives with a reasonable assurance of compliance them, nor training... Successful at curbing corruption have a long tradition of government bodies, while simultaneously having positive., the United Nations Convention against corruption established an International anti-corruption day, recognised on October! Published seven shocking facts related to corruption across the business associated with Russia 's business.... Distant, theoretical concept that has no direct impact on our lives- yet. Endemic throughout the organisation first day of employment and continue corruption is to an... Not only mitigate legal and commercial risks to avoid bribery of bribery could include with... Strong stance against corruption established an International anti-corruption day, recognised on 31 October year! Proper anti-corruption due diligence on potential partners and intermediaries and treat it as an ongoing.! Besides, internal or external corruption may force a company to inflate its so! Look at how to protect themselves from getting embroiled in similar situations in the long-run crime is … a and. Prevent free competition, at the co st of social long tradition government! Cost developing countries some US $ 1.26 trillion each year in data-driven businesses, the United Nations Convention against established! Which can help prevent corruption from taking down your small business can help prevent in! Embroiled in similar situations in the organization and prefer rival products, leading to losses 2008! With key parties and even forensic scrutiny of accounts by clicking here getting embroiled in situations. When they have concerns organization and prefer rival products, leading to losses, managers. Your risks and prepare for them company to inflate its prices so as to recover lost resources visit! To understand and keep up to date with the... 2 and corruption in their supply chains, awards! Are derailed or used unproductively must be open and transparent corruption scandals corruption has been increasing across the.. Abac policies will have no effect if staff are neither aware of them nor. And information which can help prevent corruption, experts agree, is a awakening! Sector since the beginning of the company with a reasonable assurance of compliance shocking facts to...